When Piracy Turns a Game Dev Simulation into a Bankruptcy Scenario

Launching our first game, Game Dev Tycoon, on Mac, Windows, and Linux, we decided to do something unconventional and perhaps unprecedented: we released a cracked version ourselves, mere minutes after opening our online store. We uploaded the torrent to a leading piracy site, crafted a description that mimicked the scene, and enlisted friends to seed the file. The response was immediate and striking, with our torrent client showing rapid download speeds and connections from all over the world across our three supported platforms.

This bold move was intended to serve as a mirror held up to pirates, illustrating how piracy can affect independent developers. Instead of simply warning players about illegal copies, we designed the game to display a message during gameplay, revealing the real-world consequences of piracy:

> Boss, it seems that while many players enjoy our new game, they are also stealing it by downloading cracked versions instead of purchasing legally.

> If players don’t support developers by buying their games, we will inevitably face bankruptcy.

As players spend hours building their virtual game company, they see their in-game funds dwindle as more of their creations get pirated. The virtual company eventually collapses, mirroring the harsh reality faced by many small developers. Online discussions about the experiment revealed mixed reactions: some questioned whether DRM could prevent piracy, while others expressed frustration about the industry’s reliance on piracy as a scapegoat. One user asked if implementing DRM or other anti-piracy measures might help, highlighting the ongoing debate over how to protect indie games.

Despite these concerns, the core message was clear: piracy can have devastating effects on small studios. For many indie developers, the difference between a successful project and bankruptcy hinges on every dollar earned. Our game, which costs just $8, was intentionally made DRM-free, allowing players to run it on up to three computers across different OSes and even providing a plan to include a Steam key once the game is available there. Supporting indie developers through purchases helps ensure they can continue creating innovative and fun experiences.

For those curious about trying the game before buying, a free demo is available, offering a chance to experience the simulation firsthand. Ultimately, the experiment aimed to spark a conversation about industry trends and the importance of supporting independent creators.

—

The Impact of Piracy on Small Developers

The results after just one day of release were sobering: over 93% of players used the cracked version, with at least 3,104 users accessing it compared to only 214 legitimate copies. Our game features anonymous usage tracking, which confirmed these figures. While some players may have offline or firewall restrictions, the disparity suggests a significant portion of the audience opted for piracy. This reality underscores how prevalent piracy remains, especially for smaller titles that lack the resources to enforce strict DRM measures.

Addressing Piracy and Its Consequences

To the players who downloaded the cracked copy: I am not angry. In earlier times, piracy was common because global distribution channels and payment options were limited. I understand that some individuals genuinely cannot afford the game, and I hold no grudge against them. However, for those who can support us, consider this: your purchase helps fund future projects. If you want to see more ambitious sequels or innovative titles, supporting indie developers is crucial.

Supporting creators means choosing DRM-free games and avoiding social or pay-to-play models that prioritize monetization over experience. Our game’s modest price of $8 is a small contribution to a much-needed ecosystem where developers can sustain themselves and produce more engaging content. You can enjoy the game on multiple devices, and we plan to include a Steam version to make it even more accessible.

The Role of DRM and Future Considerations

The question of whether DRM is necessary remains complex. For start-ups like us, DRM is a double-edged sword: it can inconvenience honest customers while doing little to stop determined pirates. Since any game can be cracked, efforts spent on DRM often only annoy legitimate users without providing real security. Online multiplayer games tend to rely on server-side protections, but single-player titles—like ours—are inherently vulnerable.

Personally, I love single-player experiences and hope to continue making them. If more users supported our work by purchasing our games, we could afford to develop even more ambitious projects. The broader industry trend favors intrusive DRM and always-on requirements, which often penalize paying customers while pirates find ways to bypass restrictions. This twisted world highlights the need for better solutions that balance protection with user experience.

Final Reflections from the Developer

Would I repeat the experiment? Absolutely. Releasing a cracked version to demonstrate the impact of piracy is a unique opportunity that only a game development simulation can effectively leverage. The broader idea—making pirates’ lives more difficult than those of genuine customers—could work for various games and might influence industry practices over time.

Ultimately, if more trouble is placed in the path of pirates than legitimate buyers, more players might choose to support the creators. Sadly, the current landscape often rewards pirates while penalizing honest consumers, especially in the AAA segment, where intrusive DRM and always-on requirements dominate.

To Our Genuine Customers

Thank you sincerely for your support. Your purchases make a real difference and allow us to keep creating new games. We encourage you to update to the latest version via the download link sent with your purchase. We’ve fixed many issues since launch, and your feedback is invaluable. To learn more about our upcoming projects or to see how you can support independent game development, visit our official site.

Supporting small studios through fair purchases helps ensure that more innovative, fun, and DRM-free titles can reach players worldwide. Your trust and support are what keep us going. We look forward to bringing you more enjoyable experiences in the future.

—

For further insights into game development and working with experienced studios, explore resources like this company dedicated to mobile game creation or outsourcing production tasks. If you’re interested in augmented reality projects, consider AR development in London. Our team also specializes in multiplayer game projects, which you can learn more about at this studio.