The debate over whether larger games are truly worthwhile in game development has persisted for years, especially within communities like Game Dev Tycoon enthusiasts. Many developers have experimented extensively, uncovering insights that challenge traditional assumptions about size and profitability. From balancing development costs to understanding market standards, the decision to pursue big projects involves more nuance than simply aiming for grander titles. In this discussion, we’ll explore the realities of producing large games, the comparative advantages of medium-sized projects, and strategic considerations for maximizing return on investment.
Developers often find that larger games, despite requiring significantly more time and financial resources, do not necessarily translate into proportionally higher profits. A common observation is that the profit margins from large projects tend to mirror those of medium-sized titles once all expenses are accounted for. As the game size increases, so do the challenges associated with meeting quality standards, making it more difficult to craft a truly successful large game compared to a well-made medium one. Producing a quality medium game—such as a 9.5 rating—can be considerably easier and more cost-effective than hitting the high marks needed for a large game, like an 8.5 rating.
This reality was often obscured during early gameplay attempts, where developers might rush into larger projects without fully understanding the trade-offs. However, experience reveals that the additional investment in a large game does not always yield better financial returns. While AAA titles often outperform medium games in revenue, their elevated development standards and extended timelines mean that their profitability is not guaranteed. For instance, AAA titles excel at creating massively multiplayer online games (MMOs), but only if they achieve extraordinary quality—otherwise, they might not justify the extra effort compared to a well-executed large game.
In my own gameplay, focusing on medium-sized projects allowed me to surpass previous best scores and achieve significant profits with relatively modest investments. A notable example involved developing a 9.75-rated medium game in the final year of my playthrough, which sold 14.7 million copies and generated over 157 million in profit. Interestingly, when sales exceeded 10 million units, a dialogue pop-up recognized the game’s AAA-like quality, emphasizing how well-designed medium projects can rival larger productions in market impact.
Contrary to some beliefs, producing large games requires a different approach, often involving more staff and advanced graphics engines—such as 2D v4 or 3D v3—to handle increased workload effectively. The key to success lies not only in the size of the project but also in strategic planning, including the use of advanced engine features and targeted marketing campaigns. For example, engaging a studio with expertise in multiplayer game development can be a game-changer, especially when aiming for multiplayer features or online components.
Sales performance is heavily influenced by factors beyond just development costs. A good game rating and hype generated through marketing significantly drive sales, with your existing fan base amplifying these effects. While some believe that slider adjustments in game design are a precise science, in reality, they serve more as guidelines; important sliders differ by genre, and their optimal positions are often flexible. Achieving high ratings relies on carefully balancing these sliders and incorporating relevant engine features to enhance the gaming experience.
In addition to engine features, creating sequels to successful titles can give a considerable boost to game quality and reviews. Upgrading to a new engine with expanded capabilities not only improves gameplay but also attracts more fans, increasing potential sales for future projects. For developers interested in expanding into emerging markets, such as augmented reality, exploring development of mobile games for AR presents exciting opportunities to reach new audiences.
Ultimately, the decision between focusing on large versus medium projects hinges on strategic goals, available resources, and market conditions. While big titles can be lucrative, they often require an immense investment and carry higher risks. Conversely, well-executed medium games can deliver consistent profits, especially when leveraging the right tools and marketing strategies. For those seeking to excel in multiplayer experiences or augmented reality gaming, partnering with experienced studios or investing in innovative development techniques can make all the difference.
—
Note: For further insights on creating complex multiplayer experiences, consider exploring development of multiplayer games using unity.